The New York Giants are at a crossroads. After a 3-14 season they know they need to find a franchise quarterback. With the 3rd pick in the 2025 NFL Draft and a weak quarterback class the Giants are exploring all options – including a blockbuster trade for Rams’ veteran Matthew Stafford.
The Giants’ Quarterback Dilemma
The Giants need a quarterback. Tommy DeVito is the only QB under contract and they can’t wait for the draft to address the position.
- Draft Issues: The 2025 quarterback class is thin and top prospects Cam Ward of Miami and Shedeur Sanders of Colorado may be out of reach at 3.
- Trade Options: The Giants are said to be looking to trade for 37 year old Matthew Stafford who showed in 2024 he still has some juice left.
- Free Agency: The free agent pool is weak so trades and the draft are the only options.
Joe Schoen’s Plan: ‘Take Swings’ at QB
Giants GM Joe Schoen said at the NFL Scouting Combine the team will try everything to find its next QB.
“I’m for taking swings at that position,’’ Schoen said. “It’s the most important position, and it’s hard to find ‘em, so keep swinging. Keep swinging at the position until you find one.’’
Schoen said they’ll consider all options: draft, free agency, trade. The bottom line: find a QB that gives them the best chance to win.
Matthew Stafford: The Answer?
Matthew Stafford is being targeted by the Giants. The 37 year old quarterback had a great 2024 season and is the stability the Giants need.
- Why Stafford?: He’s a proven winner with a Super Bowl ring and experience leading a young team.
- Trade Cost: Acquiring Stafford would cost draft capital but the Giants may see it as worth it.
- Short Term Fix: While Stafford isn’t a long term solution he can bridge the gap while the Giants continue to find their franchise QB.
Joe Schoen on finding a QB you believe in: pic.twitter.com/qExxr58f3a
— Paul Schwartz (@NYPost_Schwartz) February 25, 2025
Draft Options: Cam Ward and Shedeur Sanders
If the Giants are going to stick with the draft their options are limited.
- Cam Ward: The Miami quarterback is a top prospect but may not be available at 3. The Giants would have to trade up to get him.
- Shedeur Sanders: The Colorado star and son of Deion Sanders is another option but his draft stock is uncertain.
Schoen said they can’t take a quarterback just to “check the box”. They need to find the right fit even if that means looking outside the draft.
FAQs About the Giants’ Quarterback Search
Why can’t the Giants rely on Tommy DeVito?
He showed some flashes but hasn’t been consistent or has the upside to be a franchise QB. The Giants view him as a backup going forward.
Is Matthew Stafford worth the investment at 37?
Yes if the price is right. His track record is proven — Super Bowl champ, clutch performer, can elevate an offense. For a team in win now mode he’s a stopgap solution.
Can the Giants draft a QB outside the top 3?
They could but highly unlikely they’d find a franchise QB later in the draft. A Day 2 or Day 3 prospect takes time to develop and the Giants may not have the luxury of waiting for that.
What if the Giants miss out on Stafford?
If Stafford isn’t an option the Giants will pivot to drafting a QB early or signing a bridge QB in free agency. Either way failing to address the position would be a disaster for the organization.