The New York Giants made news recently by signing veteran QB Jameis Winston to a 2 year deal. But the noise around his future with the team has only gotten louder after the Giants traded up in the 1st round of the NFL Draft to take Ole Miss QB Jaxson Dart.
With Russell Wilson expected to start in 2025 and Dart being groomed as the QB of the future, Winston’s role with the Giants is unclear. Bleacher Report’s Moe Moton thinks this means a trade is coming for the veteran QB before the season.
Why the Giants Might Trade Winston?
Winston is in a tough spot on the Giants’ roster. As Moton pointed out, he’s caught between Wilson and Dart.
“Head coach Brian Daboll has named Russell Wilson the starter. Big Blue traded back into the first round for Jaxson Dart. Winston is in no man’s land between the team’s current and future starting quarterback,” Moton wrote.
While Winston would be a great mentor and locker room presence, it’s unclear if the Giants view him as more than a short term backup. If Wilson struggles or gets hurt, would the coaches turn to Winston or give Dart reps? This uncertainty might push the Giants to explore trade options.
Winston’s Value on the Market
Despite his inconsistent career, Winston has value as a backup quarterback. Last season with the Cleveland Browns he threw for 2,121 yards, 13 touchdowns and 12 interceptions in 12 games (7 starts).
For a quarterback needy team looking for depth or a bridge starter, Winston would be an attractive option. His experience and ability to step in during emergencies makes him a valuable asset even if his ceiling is limited.
Moton says the Giants should aim for an early Day 3 pick in return. Not a big haul but it would give the Giants more draft capital and clear the way for Dart to develop.
Financial Implications
One reason the Giants might trade Winston is his cheap contract. He’s signed to a backup deal so his cap hit is minimal. Whether they keep him as insurance or trade him for a small return.
If a team desperate for a QB comes calling the Giants might not be able to pass up the opportunity to get assets even if it’s just a late round pick.
What’s Next for the Giants’ QB Room?
The Giants QB situation is one of the most interesting storylines heading into 2025. Wilson is the starter for now but his play will dictate how quickly they turn to Dart.
If Winston is on the roster, he’ll be a mentor to Dart and provide veteran stability behind Wilson. But if the Giants can get even a small return for him they’ll trade him they may trade him.
Final Thoughts: A Tough Decision Ahead
Jameis Winston’s time with the Giants might be short lived despite the recent signing. With Wilson as the starter and Dart waiting in the wings Winston’s role is expendable.
If they do trade him it won’t be a surprise. Teams are always looking for experienced backups and Winston’s track record makes him a worthwhile gamble for a contender or rebuilding team.
For now all eyes are on how the Giants navigate this QB logjam and if Winston becomes a casualty of their long term plans.
Leave a Reply